USDA dietary guidelines are deceptive – C’mon?!? Give us a chance


While working in Korea in the summer of 2008 I decided to do an art activity with my kids class. We learned all about the food pyramid. But I didn’t use just any food pyramid, I used the ‘healing food pyramid‘. It was a fun activity and hopefully some of the kids came away with a little more understanding of some of the healing food choices we can make. 

Today, while sifting though my email I was disturbed to read on one of my medical news subscriptions regarding the new USDA food pyramid and dietary guidelines, ‘Lawsuit says new USDA dietary guidelines are deceptive‘.  Reading though the article I let out a sign of disappointment as once again agribusiness gets a step up, while the general public have to struggle on with confusing and incorrect dietary advice. It seems that over and over again there is opportunity to really help people fight against diseases like cancer and diabetes, to name just a few, and yet we are constantly fed misinformation, making it much more difficult to make healthy food choices. 

Though I don’t usually use food pyramids in clinic, they do have their uses. Below are two pyramids that I like and here’s why! 

The Michigan University Healing Foods Pyramid

1. It begins with WATER! Often a forgotten element in the diet. Some us live on coffee, tea, fizzy drinks or juice. The body needs pure WATER. 

2. The next level is fruit and vegetables. This pyramid makes it clear that fruit and vegetables are MORE important than grains. I feel it also conveys variety and abundance. 

3. Grains are not at the bottom of the pyramid, so they are not given undue emphasis. Grains are an important part of the diet, but not THE MOST important. Unfortunately this pyramid doesn’t specify that grains should be WHOLE grains. 

3. Legumes gets their own category. These are a wonderful part of a healthy diet, rich in essential nutrients and fibre. 

4. Healthy fats are included, an essential part of the diet! Our society is fat phobic. We have to get over this. Our brain is 60% fat and every single cell in our body is housed in a little bubble of these essential fats. If we don’t eat healthy fats, the functioning of EVERY cell in the body is compromised. Oily fish, nuts, flax, avocado and so on need to be part of the diet… Healing fats are an ESSENTIAL part of a weight loss program. 

5. It lets us know that ‘an egg a day is OKAY’. 

5. Though no food pyramid is perfect, if you follow this one, you’d be doing pretty well. 

The Vegan Food Pyramid

1. Again this pyramid starts with WATER! It specifies roughly how much water is needed, and that if you’re active you need MORE! 

2. This pyramid is more suitable for those on a gluten free, vegetarian, vegan, dairy/lactose free diet in that it shows possible alternatives. 

3. It also puts emphasis on fruit and veggies over grains and conveys that there is more to fruit and veggies than apples, oranges, carrots and peas! 

4. It does mention WHOLE grains and gives a clear indication as to the wide variety of grains available. Eating a variety of grains not only gives more varied nutrition, but lessens the likelihood that we’ll become sensitive to wheat products. 

5. Though we don’t have to be vegan 100% of the time, eating vegan and vegetarian for a portion of the week, with a good awareness of how to get enough quality protein and B12, is a very healthy way to live. This pyramid will help you get started! 

When it comes to many of the important choices that we make in our life, it would be nice to be able to put our trust in those who claim to have our best interests at heart. But at the end of the day, we have to investigate for ourselves, learn the truth and then decide. 

Best of health!

4 thoughts on “USDA dietary guidelines are deceptive – C’mon?!? Give us a chance

  1. Irene Post author

    Hopefully in time the healthy stuff will get the support from government that it deserves. But you’re right, at the moment it can cost a fortune, especially with a growing family and hungry husbands!!

  2. Irene Post author

    Thank you Kendra! Yes these pyramids are definitely a great step in the right direction. Now we just need to start eating all the lovely stuff in them!!

  3. Kendra

    Loved this post Irene!! Thank you for sharing these pyramids! Much better than the ones I’ve seen.

  4. veggiegrettie

    I love the vegan pyramid! Slowly we are changing public’s perception of health. I think more and more people will figure out that nutrition is the key…we just need to help them along.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s